Buying Singles vs Opening Booster Packs
Last reviewed:
Quick answer
Buying a single card is usually more predictable if you want one specific card. Opening packs can be more fun, but pack results are random and may cost more than buying the single directly.
Disclosure: Some links on TCG Comp are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you click and buy through TCGplayer, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
| Buying Singles | Opening Packs | |
|---|---|---|
| Predictability | Total | None per pack |
| Cost for one specific card | The market price | Often far more (see calculator) |
| Fun factor | Low | High |
| Risk | Minimal | You may pull nothing of note |
Prices, availability and market trends can change. Always check current listings before buying.
Price check (imported snapshot)
Imported TCGplayer market snapshots — prices change quickly; check current listings.
Strengths and tradeoffs
Buying Singles
Best for: Getting a specific card · Predictable spending · Deck building
- Exact card, exact price
- Condition of your choice
- Usually cheaper for any one card
- No thrill of the pull
- No bonus cards
Opening Packs
Best for: The opening experience · Bulk collection building · Gifts
- Genuinely fun
- Every pack adds to a collection
- Small chance of a big hit
- Random results
- Expected cost to hit a chase usually exceeds the single price
- Easy to overspend chasing
Our verdict
Open packs for fun and collecting. If you need a specific card, buy the single. Our Singles vs Packs tool lets you run the actual numbers for any card and pull-rate estimate.
Disclosure: Some links on TCG Comp are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you click and buy through TCGplayer, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Frequently asked questions
›When do packs beat singles?
When you value the experience itself, want lots of cards from a set, or the set’s singles are so cheap that opening is mostly entertainment. For any single expensive card, singles almost always win on cost.
›How many packs would I need to pull a 1-in-200 card?
At an estimated 1-in-200 rate you would need about 139 packs for a 50% chance and about 460 packs for a 90% chance — and even then nothing is guaranteed. That is why singles are the predictable route.